Positions of States and Organisations

This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.

379 positions

2005 (continued)

  1. IHL and ERW: Response from the Netherlands

    7 November 2005State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: WG ERW

    8. … The Netherlands has a review mechanism based on the requirements of Article 36 of AP1 which reviews both methods and means of warfare to ensure their compatibility with international law, including IHL. The mechanism was set up by Ministerial Decree of the Minister …

  2. IHL and ERW: Response from the Russian Federation

    21 October 2005State or organisation: RussiaForum: WG ERW

    The Russian Federation attaches great importance to efforts to create a mechanism to ensure that evolving arms systems comply with IHL. In order that the features of new types of weapon are in keeping with international treaties, it is planned to set up a special …

  3. IHL and ERW: Response from Brazil

    12 September 2005State or organisation: BrazilForum: WG ERW

    31. In each Force there is a sectors responsible for the continuous review of military doctrines, which includes the need to assess the legality of new methods and means of warfare.

  4. IHL and ERW: Response from Denmark

    17 August 2005State or organisation: DenmarkForum: WG ERW

    10. The Danish procurement procedures underline the responsibility to guarantee that conventions and humanitarian laws accepted by Denmark are respected in the procurement. In research, development, procurement, acquisition or choice of new weapons the procurement organization has the responsibility to conduct a technical evaluation of …

  5. IHL and ERW: Response from France

    11 August 2005State or organisation: FranceForum: WG ERW

    16. The action of designing a weapon for a specific purpose is indeed an action in application of the principle of discrimination. It is complemented, within an overall legal approach, by the fulfilment of the obligations stemming from article 36 of the first additional Protocol …

  6. IHL and ERW: Response from New Zealand

    5 August 2005State or organisation: New ZealandForum: WG ERW

    19. All new weapons and ammunition types that are under consideration for acquisition by or for the NZDF are to be vetted by Directorate of Legal Services (DLS) to ensure that they comply with LOAC. 20. Vetting of weapon and ammunition types will include regard …

  7. IHL and ERW: Response from Austria

    4 August 2005State or organisation: AustriaForum: WG ERW

    16. In compliance with Article 36 Additional Protocol I every new weapon, means or method of warfare is made subject to an examination with the purpose of determining if its employment would be in some or all circumstances prohibited according to Additional Protocol I or …

  8. IHL and ERW: Response from Japan

    4 August 2005State or organisation: JapanForum: WG ERW

    14. Although Japan does not have a specific mechanism solely for the review described in the question, it considers it obvious that Japan should implement the obligation in Article 36 of the Protocol I and review the legality of new weapons.

  9. IHL and ERW: Response from Switzerland

    3 August 2005State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: WG ERW

    33. Switzerland has implemented a review mechanism within the defence structure. At the beginning of a procurement process, the IHL section of the staff of the chief of the armed forces is consulted by the organization in charge for the procurement project. The IHL-section may …

  10. IHL and ERW: Response from Argentina

    2 August 2005State or organisation: ArgentinaForum: WG ERW

    5. It is clear that CIDA’s opinion covers not only measures planned for use but also measures applicable to the design of such munitions/submunitions. These views are reproduced below as being of interest. … (vii) In all projects for and designs of new weapons, the …

  11. IHL and ERW: Response from Germany

    2 August 2005State or organisation: GermanyForum: WG ERW

    37. The Legal Affairs Directorate of the Federal Ministry of Defense is responsible for Federal Armed Forces issues within the area of legal competence of the ministry. In the framework of the review process, the directorate has due regard, inter alia, to the “Manual regarding …

  12. IHL and ERW: Response from Norway

    2 August 2005State or organisation: NorwayForum: WG ERW

    33. The Norwegian Minister of Defence appointed in 2003 the so-called “Norwegian Chief of Defence International Law Committee”. This committee is responsible for assisting the Chief of Defence in legal reviews during the process of developing, acquiring or adoption of any new weapons, methods or …

  13. IHL and ERW: Response from Sweden

    2 August 2005State or organisation: SwedenForum: WG ERW

    9. In 1974 the Government established a Delegation for International Humanitarian Law Monitoring of Arms Projects (see Ordinance concerning monitoring of arms projects in accordance with the requirements of international law, 1994:536). Its task is to examine all weapon projects not only with respect to …

  14. IHL and ERW: Response from Australia

    29 July 2005State or organisation: AustraliaForum: WG ERW

    14. Weapon review compliance is also an issue taken seriously by the Australian Defence Force. An Instruction dealing with the legal review of new weapons came into force on 02 June 2005. This requires the legal review of all proposed new weapons to determine whether …

  15. IHL and ERW: Response from the United States

    25 July 2005State or organisation: United StatesForum: WG ERW

    29. The United States does have a mechanism to review the legality of new weapons. Pursuant to DOD Directives and Military Department regulations, a legal review is required for every new or modified weapon or weapons system. In 1974, the first DOD Directive on this …

  16. IHL and ERW: Response from Canada

    29 June 2005State or organisation: CanadaForum: WG ERW

    30. Canada views the review process of weapons systems for IHL compliance to be an important topic in any discussion of the wider or more specific aspects of IHL implementation. In accordance with Article 36 of Additional Protocol I, Canada conducts legal reviews during the …

  17. IHL and ERW: Response from the United Kingdom

    24 June 2005State or organisation: United KingdomForum: WG ERW

    1. The United Kingdom recognises that all explosive munitions are capable of becoming Explosive Remnants of War. This is because all explosive ordnance is capable of failing to explode as intended. The United Kingdom therefore considers that the question relates to the use of all …

2004

  1. United Kingdom, Military Manual

    2004State or organisation: United KingdomForum: Domestic

    6.20 States party to Additional Protocol I are under an obligation ‘in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare . . . to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by [Additional …

2001

  1. Canada, Military Manual

    13 August 2001State or organisation: CanadaForum: Domestic

    530. Development of Acquisition of New Weapons 1. In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, there is an obligation to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by the LOAC. AP …