Positions of States and Organisations

This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.

379 positions

2015 (continued)

  1. Statement by the Netherlands

    April 2015State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: MX LAWS 2015

    … we also see value to further discuss the idea of a peer review process on Article 36.

  2. Statement by the United Kingdom

    April 2015State or organisation: United KingdomForum: MX LAWS 2015

    From our perspective, to discuss LAWS is to discuss means and methods of warfare. As such, international humanitarian law provides the appropriate paradigm for discussion. To that end, we look forward to sharing our views on the process of Legal Weapons Review. That is a …

  3. Statement by the United Kingdom

    April 2015State or organisation: United KingdomForum: MX LAWS 2015

    3. The UK takes its obligations under IHL extremely seriously. As required by Additional Protocol 1 to the Geneva Convention, the UK conducts legal reviews of weapons in accordance with Article 36 of the Protocol. The UK is aware that despite the large numbers of …

2014

  1. Norway, Answer to parliamentary question

    7 October 2014State or organisation: NorwayForum: Domestic

    Spørsmål Kåre Simensen (A): Hva vil regjeringen gjøre for at Norge kan bidra til å møte utfordringene utlikningen av mer avansert våpenteknologi reiser for krigens folkerett? Grunngiving Det er viktig å bidra til klare rammer for internasjonal forsvarsindustri, og at man sikrer strenge internasjonale regler …

  2. Statement by Australia

    16 May 2014State or organisation: AustraliaForum: MX LAWS 2014

    As Australia noted in its opening statement, the last four days have reinforced the need to thoroughly review all new weapons and weapon system technology against the requirements of international humanitarian law or any rule of international law applicable to the reviewing party. This is …

  3. Statement by Germany

    16 May 2014State or organisation: GermanyForum: MX LAWS 2014

    Could it be possible to create more transparency about national policies with regard to new weapons systems as well as transparency about the mechanisms to text and validate these weapons systems before deployment? The Article 36-reviews may play an important role.

  4. Statement by the ICRC

    16 May 2014State or organisation: ICRCForum: MX LAWS 2014

    Many delegations this week stressed the importance of legal reviews of autonomous weapons. The ICRC welcomes the wide recognition of the need to carry out thorough legal reviews of the new technologies of warfare they are developing or acquiring, including weapons that have autonomy in …

  5. Summary by Mali as friend of the Chair

    16 May 2014State or organisation: MaliForum: MX LAWS 2014

    L’idée qui a eu le maximum d’adhésion des délégations a été celle relative à la nécessité d’entreprendre le réexamen de la légalité sur l’étude, le développement et l’acquisition de nouvelles armes, tel que le prévoient l’article 36 du premier protocole additionnel et les règles du …

  6. Statement by Article 36

    15 May 2014State or organisation: Article 36Forum: MX LAWS 2014

    We are pleased that article 36 reviews of weapons, means and methods of warfare, have been a focus of discussion here as well. Such reviews will need to be based on an understanding of the requirement to ensure meaningful human control over such weapons systems. …

  7. Statement by Australia

    14 May 2014State or organisation: AustraliaForum: MX LAWS 2014

    It is Australia’s view that how a LAWS might be employed is an essential part of conducting an article 36 review for compliance with IHL. This also involves understanding how militaries undertake operations and the targeting process. A few States present have publically disclosed this …

  8. Statement by Germany

    14 May 2014State or organisation: GermanyForum: MX LAWS 2014

    To verify compliance with the two rules listed above [ie, prohibition of indiscriminate weapons and weapons that cause unnecessary suffering], a State intent on fielding a new weapon must conduct a thorough legal review. This requirement for a legal review, which appears in Article 36 …

  9. Statement by Australia

    13 May 2014State or organisation: AustraliaForum: MX LAWS 2014

    Recent discussions have in particular looked at the application of existing international humanitarian law (IHL) to the potential development of Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems. As a party to Additional Protocol I of 1977 to the Geneva Conventions of 1949, Australia fully supports and has a …

  10. Statement by Switzerland

    13 May 2014State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: MX LAWS 2014

    Le fait de posséder une base légale solide ne devrait pas pour autant nous amener à faire preuve de complaisance. Bien au contraire, certains aspects légaux doivent être réaffirmés et soulignés. Une question devra notamment être abordée : celle de savoir si la réalisation des …

  11. Statement by Mexico

    May 2014State or organisation: MexicoForum: MX LAWS 2014

    Además, reconocemos la aplicabilidad, en esta materia, de los limites y obligaciones preventivas previstas en el derecho internacional humanitario. Entre otros, la obligación de revisión prevista en el artículo 36 del Protcolo Adicional I a los Convenios de Ginebra, obliga a los Estados a asegurar …

  12. Statement by Sweden

    May 2014State or organisation: SwedenForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Before the deployment of any new weapon system, including one that is autonomous, there is an obligation to conduct a review of the means and methods of warfare in accordance with Article 36 of Additional Protocol I.

  13. Statement by Switzerland (May 2014)

    2014State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: MX LAWS 2014

    Dans le domaine juridique, nous relevons également l'importance attachée à la thématique de l'examen juridique des méthodes et moyens de guerre lors de nos discussions. Il s'agit là certainement d'un sujet central à préciser plus avant, tout comme la thématique de la responsabilité et la …

2013

  1. Norway, Military Manual

    2013State or organisation: NorwayForum: Domestic

    New weapons – requirement of an international law weapons review 8.9 In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, Norway is under an obligation to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited …

2012

  1. United States, International Law in Cyberspace

    18 September 2012State or organisation: United States

    States should undertake a legal review of weapons, including those that employ a cyber capability. Such a review should entail an analysis, for example, of whether a particular capability would be inherently indiscriminate, i.e., that it could not be used consistent with the principles of …

2006

  1. Australia, Military Manual

    11 May 2006State or organisation: AustraliaForum: Domestic

    4.1 Weapons, projectiles, materials and means of warfare which cause unnecessary injury or suffering are not permissible, that is, when the practical effect is to cause injury or suffering which is out of proportion to the military effectiveness of the weapon, projectile, material or means. …

  2. IHL and ERW: Response from China

    3 March 2006State or organisation: ChinaForum: WG ERW

    3. … Senior functional agencies have been set up in general staff departments and military procurement departments to review the legality of new weapons, new methods of waging war and proposed new military theories.

  3. IHL and ERW: Response from Portugal

    17 February 2006State or organisation: PortugalForum: WG ERW

    8. Yes. The applicable international instruments adopted by Portugal are taken into consideration in armament acquisition programs. The legal instruments are the national decrees transposing those instruments into the Portuguese law system.

  4. IHL and ERW: Response from Ireland

    10 February 2006State or organisation: IrelandForum: WG ERW

    16. All Defence Forces personnel engaged in weapons procurement and formulation of militarydoctrine have access to military legal advice.

  5. IHL and ERW: Response from Mexico

    10 February 2006State or organisation: MexicoForum: WG ERW

    20. In keeping with article 36 of Additional Protocol I of 1977, as well as other provisions of international law, Mexico has machinery which reviews the lawfulness of the manufacture, purchase, transfer, storage, sale, import, export, possession and carrying of weapons, ammunition and explosives. 21. …

  6. IHL and ERW: Response from South Africa

    10 February 2006State or organisation: South AfricaForum: WG ERW

    10. Yes. The South African Government has promulgated the National Conventional Arms Control Act (41 of 2002) whereby the National Conventional Arms Control Committee (situated at the DOD) review legality of new weapons and their impact on the method of warfare and military doctrine. The …

  7. IHL and ERW: Response from the Czech Republic

    10 February 2006State or organisation: CzechiaForum: WG ERW

    16. Unfortunately, the legal service of the Czech Armed Forces is currently not explicitly tasked to review legality of any new weapons. This is made rather on ad-hoc basis or within military and industrial testing. Therefore, this is an area, where a system improvement is …

2005

  1. IHL and ERW: Response from Lithuania

    22 November 2005State or organisation: LithuaniaForum: WG ERW

    19. Legal advice is available at most of the stages of the procurement of the equipment.

  2. IHL and ERW: Response from Finland

    14 November 2005State or organisation: FinlandForum: WG ERW

    10. As an example in relation to this, we could mention the procedure of reporting on security and defence policy, which presents e.g. military threats, grounds for the development of the defence system as well as supporting society and the effects of international (humanitarian) conventions …

  3. IHL and ERW: Response from Croatia

    11 November 2005State or organisation: CroatiaForum: WG ERW

    18. The mechanism of reviewing the legality of new weapons is regulated by the Article 19 of the Law on Production, Overhaul and Trade of Armament and Military Equipment (“Official Gazette” No. 33/02 and 173/03) in which it is stated: “the armament and military equipment …

  4. IHL and ERW: Response from Belgium

    9 November 2005State or organisation: BelgiumForum: WG ERW

    14. In accordance with article 36 of Additional Protocol No. 1 to the Geneva Conventions, a commission has been set up in the Belgian armed forces to evaluate new weapons, means and methods of warfare from the legal standpoint. 15. The Commission’s task is to …

  5. IHL and ERW: Response from Estonia

    7 November 2005State or organisation: EstoniaForum: WG ERW

    9. At the moment Estonia does not possess such mechanism of review. If needed, such analysis will be done on a case-by-case basis to maximize compliance with IHL.