This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.
379 positions
2019 (continued)
Statement by Brazil
Brazil acknowledges the importance of weapons reviews in order to support compliance with IHL in the use of novel weapons systems, both under Article 36 of Protocol II [sic!] to the Geneva Conventions and as a corollary of customary international law.
Statement by Canada
DND/CAF’s Legal Weapons Review Process Canada conducts legal reviews of new weapons, means, and methods of warfare that are being contemplated for study, development, acquisition, or adoption by the Department of Defenceand the Canadian Armed Forces to ensure their compliance with international law. As part …
Statement by Greece
… the provisions of Article 36 of [AP I] provides us with the necessary framework to ensure that the use of weapon systems will be in compliance with the cardinal principles of IHL in all circumstances of use.
Statement by Ireland
The conduct of legal reviews of new weapons, means and methods of war under article 36 of [AP I] is important for ensuring that the development, deployment and use of new weapons systems and new means and methods of warfare comply with international law. As …
Statement by the European Union
We recall that national legal weapons reviews must be conducted, pursuant to Article 36 of [AP I], in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, in order to determine whether its employment would, in some or all …
Statement by the Netherlands
On weapon reviews procedures. To further IHL compliance, the Netherlands is of the opinion that (1) the implementation of Article 36 procedures should be promoted (2) the concept of meaningful human control should play an important role within the Article 36 review and that (3) …
Statement by the Netherlands
… meaningful human control should consider, inter alia, the following elements: (3) The execution of legal weapon reviews that pay sufficient attention to the level of autonomy of the weapon system.
Statement by Finland
We feel that our discussions should actually reflect the issue of trust: trust between a human and the machine in respect to the authorisation of force. Only trusted systems can be authorized to execute tasks defined by humans. To ascertain this trust, we emphasize the …
Statement by Italy
For Italy, the starting point of this debate has always been that the development, deployment and use of any weapons system, including possible LAWS, must comply with the rules and principles of International Humanitarian Law. In our view, this encompasses the rules on the conduct …
Statement of the European Union
All States must ensure that emerging technologies including Artificial Intelligence that could be used in [LAWS] are developed and used in compliance with international law, in particular [IHL]. National legal weapons reviews in compliance with IHL remain a relevant tool in this context. Humans need …
Possible outcome of 2019 GGE and future actions of international community on LAWS
Concerning confidence building measures, it is appropriate to consider what kind of mechanism is suitable in order to secure transparency. Introducing an implementation mechanism of weapons review into the annual report of the CCW may work as one of such mechanisms.
Potential opportunities and limitations of military uses of lethal autonomous weapons systems
8. Article 36 of 1977 Additional Protocol I (AP I) to the Geneva Conventions of 1949 is a supplementary tool to regulate LAWS in the context of future military uses. Russia adheres to its relevant obligations and deems it unnecessary to elaborate a universal mandatory …
Statement by Greece
As we have already outlined, the use of algorithms with the ability of learning in weapons raises concerns which revolve around to their predictability and reliability on the battlefield. Therefore, it is of utmost importance to verify that any weapon with a high degree of …
New Zealand, Military Manual
Section 4 – Weapons and Munitions Review 7.4.1 Members of the NZDF responsible for the development, acquisition or bringing into service of weapons and munitions for use by the NZDF are to ensure that those weapons and munitions comply with LOAC. As early as possible …
2018
Statement by Italy
We also welcomed the shared reiteration that rules and principles of [IHL] must apply to all weapons systems, including LAWS. We continue to believe that our engagement towards the full implementation of, and respect for, the rules and principles of IHL must stand firm independently …
The Australian Article 36 Review Process
1. Article 36 of the Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts, 8 June 1977 (Additional Protocol 1), provides: “In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means …
Statement by Belgium
We have a powerful instrument at our disposal to ensure that we do not put into service non IHL compliant weapons. This is Article 36 of [AP I] on the evaluation of the lawfulness of all new weapons. Belgium has put this instrument into practice …
Statement by Bulgaria
In our view, conducting legal weapon reviews under Article 36 of [AP I] serves as an important tool to assure that use and development of [AWS] is in compliance with IHL rules and regulations. Considering the multidimensional and intricate nature of LAWS, the processes of …
Statement by Finland
The obligation to carry out legal reviews of new weapons under article 36 of [AP I] is crucial for ensuring that a State’s armed forces are capable of conducting hostilities in accordance with its international obligations. We call for the universalization of this important protocol …
Statement by Norway
We stress, however, that the development and use of new military technologies, including autonomous technologies for military purposes, do not take place in a legal vacuum. We therefore see merit in further discussion and information sharing on how existing regulation, including national Article 36 processes, …
Statement by Poland
Having a common characterization of LAWS, or at least, a set of the key characteristics, would be a prerequisite for seeking future policy options. Pointing to these options, Poland underlines the significance of application of “Article 36 review” as essential to determining whether the adoption …
Statement by Switzerland
[A political declaration] could spell out a number of measures such as transparency, legal reviews, best practices, technical standards or other policy measures.
Statement by the Non-Aligned Movement
Regarding different proposals on a political declaration, code of conduct and other voluntary measures, including weapons review process, as well as the establishment of a Committee of Experts, NAM believes that these measures cannot be a substitute for the objective of concluding a legally binding …
Human-Machine Interaction in the Development, Deployment and Use of Emerging Technologies in the Area of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems
32. We also recommend a proactive approach in addressing issues in human-machine interaction. States seeking to develop new uses for autonomy in their weapons should be affirmatively seeking to identify and address these issues in their respective processes for managing the life cycle of such …
Human Machine Touchpoints: The United Kingdom’s perspective on human control over weapon development and targeting cycles
11. … Assessment, evaluation and revision of both the system and the surrounding political, strategic, operational and tactical ‘wrap’ is a continuous cycle rather than a linear, sequential process and a combination of factors are required to ensure human control at the appropriate points. These …
Statement by Austria
There seems to be convergence of views on the importance and the merits, but also limitations of article 36. Weapon reviews constitute a critical national implementation mechanism to establish the legality of weapon, means or method of warfare. Article 36 is very valuable in that …
Statement by Germany
Legal/Ethical Issues […] Germany remains fully committed to the implementation of Article 36 of the Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions (Protocol I), concerning the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare. As previously stated, in 2016 Germany …
Statement by Italy
I believe that the starting point should remain a common, shared recognition that our engagement towards the full implementation of, and respect for, the rules and principles of IHL must stand firm independently of the specificity of any weapons system. I am referring not only …
Statement by New Zealand
At this stage, we are particularly interested in the existing obligation that all States Parties to [AP I] have to assess the compliance with IHL of all weapons, means and methods of warfare, including LAWS — through weapons reviews. These reviews serve as an existing …
Statement by Switzerland
A first example for concrete work in the CCW — whether triggered by a political declaration as just referred to, or by a more specific GGE mandate — are weapons reviews: This week showed again the centrality of the obligation to conduct legal reviews in …