Positions of States and Organisations

This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.

379 positions

2018 (continued)

  1. Working Paper on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems

    3 April 2018State or organisation: PolandForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Development and use of LAWS should remain in compliance with the international law, in particular with the [IHL] and the international human rights law. According to Article 36 of [API] states should determine the lawfulness of any new weapon or means or method of warfare …

  2. General principles on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems

    28 March 2018State or organisation: NAMForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Regarding different proposals on a political declaration, code of conduct and other voluntary measures, including weapons review process, as well as the establishment of a Committee of Experts, NAM believes that these measures cannot be a substitute for the objective of concluding a legally binding …

2017

  1. Statement by Estonia

    16 November 2017State or organisation: EstoniaForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    … A number of states have highlighted the importance of conducting legal reviews of new weapons systems as an implementation mechanism of international humanitarian law. Estonia would support a further discussion on best practices of weapons reviews, especially as concerns technologically complex weapon systems. Estonia …

  2. Statement by Venezuela on behalf of NAM

    16 November 2017State or organisation: NAMForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    Regarding different proposals on a political declaration, code of conduct and other voluntary measures, including weapons review process as well as the establishment of the committee of experts, NAM believes that this measure cannot be substitute for the objective concluding a legally binding instrument.

  3. Statement by China

    15 November 2017State or organisation: ChinaForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    We have noted that some countries proposed a self-review of the legitimacy of weapons at the stage of their R&D. In our view, although national reviews of a weapons have some positive role and many countries, including China, have relevant mechanisms for review and assessment, …

  4. Statement by Switzerland

    15 November 2017State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    … with regard to legal reviews, there appears to be consensus that autonomous weapon systems qualify as weapons in the sense of Article 36 of Additional Protocol 1 and are the subject to a new weapons review process like any other weapon. In this regard, …

  5. Statement by Austria

    13 November 2017State or organisation: AustriaForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    The basis for the assessment of lawfulness of new weapons is inter alia enshrined in Article 36 of [AP I]. We encourage all States to strenuously conduct legal weapon reviews for all possible future weapons.

  6. Statement by Germany

    13 November 2017State or organisation: GermanyForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    We believe that this GGE should consider exploring concrete options for transparency and confidence building. In our view voluntary measures that could increase confidence between States and enhance compliance with the existing regulations such as Article 36 of [AP I] include establishing transparency and facilitating …

  7. Statement by New Zealand

    13 November 2017State or organisation: New ZealandForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    We can also see much value in pursuing greater transparency and information exchange regarding the conduct of Article 36 reviews. At the same time, we can see that no one approach is sufficient to resolve the many concerns that have been raised about LAWS, in …

  8. Statement by the European Union

    13 November 2017State or organisation: European UnionForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    The EU recalls that States Parties to [AP I] are required to conduct legal weapons reviews which is a key mechanism to establish, in each specific case, whether or not possible future LAWS can be developed, produced or used lawfully. The EU and its Member …

  9. Autonomy in weapon systems

    10 November 2017State or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    3. The United States of America views the review of the legality of weapons as a best practice for implementing customary and treaty law relating to weapons and their use in armed conflict. The United States of America is not a party to [AP I] …

  10. A “compliance-based” approach to autonomous weapons

    10 November 2017State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    19. Under IHL, the substantive rules described above are complemented by a procedural rule. As with any other weapon, means or method of warfare, States have the positive obligation to determine, in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of any [AWS], whether their employment would, …

  11. For consideration by the Group of Governmental Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems

    7 November 2017State or organisation: FranceState or organisation: GermanyForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    C. Options for transparency and confidence building 9. Voluntary measures that could enhance compliance with the existing regulations (Article 36 of [AP I] on weapons reviews) and increase confidence between States include: (a) Establishing transparency and facilitating the identification of best-practices in conducting weapons reviews …

  12. Weapons review mechanisms

    7 November 2017State or organisation: NetherlandsState or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    I. Summary 1. Limitations on the choice of methods and means of warfare can already be found in the oldest sources of international humanitarian law and were repeated and re-established in article 35 of the First Additional protocol (AP1). The preamble of the Convention on …

  13. Examination of various dimensions of emerging technologies in the area of lethal autonomous weapons systems

    9 October 2017State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: GGE LAWS 2017

    16. For most states, weapon reviews are compulsory based on Article 36 of [API], which obliges States Parties involved in the development or acquisition of new means and methods of warfare to determine whether they are permitted under international law. The Netherlands is of the …

2016

  1. Denmark, Military Manual

    September 2016State or organisation: DenmarkForum: Domestic

    10. Weapons Review 9.19. In connection with Denmark’s study, development, acquisition, or adoption of a new weapon, means, or method of warfare, Denmark is under an obligation to determine whether its employment, in some or all circumstances, would be prohibited by AP I or by …

  2. Presentation of the Belgian Commission of the Legal Review of New Weapons

    13 April 2016State or organisation: BelgiumForum: MX LAWS 2016

    The Belgian Commission for the Legal Review of New Weapons was established by the General Order-J/836 issued by the Chief of Defence on 18th July 2002. The establishment of the Commission aimed at formalizing the respect of the obligation coming out of article 36. The …

  3. Statement by Israel

    13 April 2016State or organisation: IsraelForum: MX LAWS 2016

    It seems widely accepted that, like every other means of warfare, the use of LAWS is subject to the Law of Armed Conflict. Another observation that seems to be widely supported, regards the importance of conducting legal reviews of weapons, including LAWS. Israel would like …

  4. Statement by Switzerland

    13 April 2016State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: MX LAWS 2016

    In this context, the obligation to conduct legal reviews is central to discussions on autonomous weapons systems. We see a number of challenges related to autonomous weapons systems distinct from traditional weapons reviews. Specifically, the question is how such systems and their specific characteristics can …

  5. Non-Paper of France

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: FranceForum: MX LAWS 2016

    L’article 36 du premier Protocole additionnel aux Conventions de Genève du 12 août 1949 (PA I), en exigeant que les États parties vérifient la conformité au DIH des nouvelles armes, moyens ou méthodes de guerre, témoigne de la continuité d’application du DIH au développement et …

  6. Opening Statement by the Netherlands

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: MX LAWS 2016

    Please allow me, to summarize explain in summary the Dutch position: […] 9. Autonomous weapon systems need to remain under meaningful human control. Therefore it is important that when procuring autonomous weapons, the government should ensure that (1). the concept of morally responsible engineering is …

  7. Statement by Australia

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: AustraliaForum: MX LAWS 2016

    May I reaffirm at the outset that Australia takes seriously our responsibilities under the existing legal framework for reviewing new weapons under Article 36 of Additional Protocol I of 1977 to the Geneva Conventions of 1949. We fully support and adhere to the obligation to …

  8. Statement by Canada

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: CanadaForum: MX LAWS 2016

    … increased transparency and information-sharing around guidelines and best practices for weapons reviews could play an important role in assisting States fulfill their Article 36 obligations with regards to LAWS.

  9. Statement by Finland

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: FinlandForum: MX LAWS 2016

    We further underline, that each and every state has the ultimate responsibility in every situation where norms of international humanitarian or human rights law are breached. This includes of course the provisions in the Geneva conventions first additional protocol on the review of the legality …

  10. Statement by Germany

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: GermanyForum: MX LAWS 2016

    Fourthly, without LAWS being a reality yet and without even a definition of LAWS transparency and confidence building measures especially with regard to the introduction of new weapons systems are of crucial importance. We should therefor make full use of the process of Legal Weapons …

  11. Statement by Germany

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: GermanyForum: MX LAWS 2016

    Technology develops in unforeseeable ways and comes in virtually unlimited varieties of shapes and modes of action. Given this challenge, it is for good reason that the fundamental principles of international humanitarian law avoid specifying particular technologies. The general, abstract approach of international humanitarian law …

  12. Statement by Sierra Leone

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: Sierra LeoneForum: MX LAWS 2016

    We have heard conflicting views as to whether LAWS could be in conformity with IHL. My delegation trusts that all States would like to operate within the provisions of International Humanitarian Law and would take steps to respect Article 36 of the Additional Protocol 1 …

  13. Statement by Sri Lanka

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: Sri LankaForum: MX LAWS 2016

    … establishing evidence that the operator or the manufacturers knew or should have known the possibility of the crime committed by a complicated artificial intelligence system fed into the weapon will be a difficult task. Therefore, we recommend this aspect also be given due attention …

  14. Statement by Sweden

    11–15 April 2016State or organisation: SwedenForum: MX LAWS 2016

    We would like to contribute to the discussion with a brief account of the Swedish experiences of the Article 36 review process. The Swedish Delegation for International Humanitarian Law Monitoring of Arms Projects (the Delegation) was established in The Delegation is an independent authority and …

  15. Statement by the ICRC

    11 April 2016State or organisation: ICRCForum: MX LAWS 2016

    The ICRC welcomes the recognition by States of the importance of reviewing new weapons to ensure their compatibility with international law, and stresses that efforts to strengthen national legal review processes are complementary and mutually reinforcing of discussions at the international level, in particular in …