This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.
379 positions
2021 (continued)
Statement by Sweden
Going forward, the GGE needs to continue to examine and clarify the type of normative or regulatory framework needed to effectively address issues related to emerging technologies in the area of LAWS. The GGE should also further explore how weapons reviews can be enhanced and …
Comments by New Zealand on the Chair’s paper
We welcome the inclusion of this section on weapons reviews. New Zealand believes weapons reviews, including article 36 reviews, will continue to play an important role in weapons development. Our overarching comment is that we think consideration should be given to making these reviews more …
Voluntary national contribution of Brazil on the subject of how international law applies to the use of information and communications technologies by States
… according to AP I, States have an obligation, “in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare,” to “determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances,” be prohibited.40 This norm, although being less strict than …
Voluntary national contributions of Germany on the subject of how international law applies to the use of information and communications technologies by States
The obligation to take precautions in attack is complemented by the obligation to conduct weapon reviews of any new means or method of cyber warfare to determine whether its employment would, in some or in all circumstances, be prohibited by international law.96 The findings of …
Written contribution of Poland on possible consensus recommendations
6. The Group will also consider facilitating a voluntary exchange of national practices and experiences, where they exist, in the area of legal reviews of new weapons, according to Article 36 of [API].
Australia’s submission on International Law to be Annexed to the Report of the 2021 Group of Governmental Experts on Cyber
Australia, and other States parties to Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions of 1949 are required under Article 36 to determine whether the employment of new weapons, or means or method of warfare, would, in some or all circumstances be prohibited by Additional Protocol …
National Commentary by Canada
Canada implements a permanent national legal review of all of its weapons systems. Canada fully complies with Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, which requires states to determine whether new weapons, means or methods of warfare may be employed lawfully under …
Possible recommendations in relation to the clarification, consideration and development of aspects of the normative and operational framework
D. Weapon reviews High Contracting Parties, at their Sixth Review Conference, confirm that in the study, development, acquisition, or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, States are under an obligation to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, …
Written contribution of Finland on possible consensus recommendations
Weapon systems including autonomous features or functions and the intended military task to be resolved require contextual review. To determine compliance/non-compliance with IHL of LAWS for the given task in certain circumstances, three interlinked key elements should be studied in all phases of preparation and …
Written Contribution of the European Union on Possible Consensus Recommendations
Weapons reviews A normative and operational framework Should acknowledge that national legal weapon reviews provide an important framework to determine whether a new weapons system, means or method of warfare can be used in compliance with international law. In accordance with States’ obligations under international …
Switzerland’s Position Paper on the Application of International Law in Cyberspace
States and parties to a conflict have an overarching obligation to “respect and ensure respect” for IHL “in all circumstances”. It is uncontested that preparatory measures must be taken to implement IHL and that its implementation needs to be supervised. This requires states and parties …
Opinion on the Integration of Autonomy into Lethal Weapon Systems
c) Compliance: ensure legality is correctly monitored throughout the life cycle of weapon systems (126) Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 relating to the protection of victims of international armed conflicts of 8 June 1977 (Protocol I) …
Germany, On the Application of International Law in Cyberspace
The obligation to take precautions in attack is complemented by the obligation to conduct weapon reviews of any new means or method of cyber warfare to determine whether its employment would, in some or in all circumstances, be prohibited by international law. The findings of …
Elements for a Future Normative Framework
Recommendations towards a normative framework 11. In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of any AWS, States must be able to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by IHL or any other applicable rule of international law. It is …
Food for thought by Switzerland
4. Weapons Reviews An implementation of IHL in good faith requires an assessment whether means and methods of warfare can be used in conformity with IHL prior to their employment in international as well as non-international armed conflicts. Conducting legal reviews, as specified in article …
Joint submission on possible consensus recommendations
IV. Weapons Reviews Weapons reviews, including art. 36 reviews, will continue to play an important role in weapons development. In the evaluation of weapons systems based on emerging technologies in the area of LAWS, key challenges in the regulation and the nature of the systems …
National Commentary by the Philippines
Having agreed upon these general premises, there is now enough basis to negotiate a legally-binding Protocol under the Convention that will contain prohibitions or regulations in the area of LAWS and other advanced weapon systems. The GGE should now be given the mandate to discuss …
Written contribution of Canada on potential consensus recommendations
… We also ensure strict adherence to IHL throughout the lifecycle of the weapon. In accordance with Article 36 of [API], Canada conducts national legal reviews of new weapons, means or methods of warfare, to ensure IHL compliance. Canada also strictly adheres to IHL in …
Written contribution of Spain on possible consensus recommendations
States should assess, through legal reviews, whether human involvement in the new system would violate IHL principles. In case a legal review identifies a use that might be problematic, doctrine and training should be drafted and implemented in such a way that they allow the …
2020
Norway, Letter to the defense sector
2.1.4.5.2 Vurdering av våpen og krigføringsmetoder Norge er etter første tilleggsprotokoll til Genèvekonvensjonene, artikkel 36, i forbindelse med gjennomføring av studier, utvikling, anskaffelse eller godkjenning av et nytt våpen eller nye krigføringsmetoder eller -virkemidler, forpliktet til å avklare om bruken i sin alminnelighet eller i …
Statement by the Netherlands
The Netherlands considers weapons reviews — mandatory for us under international law — crucial for all weapon systems, including weapon systems with some degree of autonomy. A better understanding of how weapon reviews work and sharing experiences and best practices will contribute to improve the …
Statement by the United States
Additionally, Guiding Principle (e) reaffirms the importance of a robust practice of conducting reviews of the legality of weapons. Such reviews are a good practice to facilitate the implemen-tation of international law applicable to weapons and their use in armed conflict, and can also help …
Statement by Costa Rica
Mi delegación es de la firme convicción que esta revisión legal integral por expertos legales y como parte de un intercambio amplio e inclusivo con expertos operativos y tecnológicos debe 3 realizarse de manera enfocada, y tomando como base los avances logrados ya por el …
Statement by the Netherlands
Turning to the issue of the development and testing of weapons, the Netherlands wishes to emphasize once again the importance of legal weapon reviews. As a State Party to [API], the Netherlands has a standing legal review process for all new weapons, means and methods …
National Commentary by Austria
The legal weapon review outlined in Article 36 of the Geneva Additional Protocol of 1949 requires that "In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, a High Contracting Party is under an obligation to determine whether its …
National Commentary by the United Kingdom
As pointed out in the 2019 report of the GGE, exchange of good practice relating to key activities such as legal weapon reviews could be beneficial. We continue to believe this has merit and believe it not only to be an area worthy of focus, …
National Commentary by the United States
This guiding principle reaffirms the principle in Article 36 of the 1977 Additional Protocol I to the 1949 Geneva Conventions. The United States is not a party to the Additional Protocol I and does not regard Article 36 as reflecting customary law, but engages in …
National Commentary by the Netherlands
The Netherlands is a State Party to Additional Protocol I of the Geneva Conventions (AP I) and has a standing legal review process for all new weapons, means and methods of warfare as well as for all modifications to existing weapons, means and methods of …
National Commentary by the Russian Federation
In accordance with guiding principle e), the Russian Federation fully complies with its obligations under Article 36 of the AP I. We consider it a norm of customary international law. This Article has no provisions on how exactly legal reviews should be conducted, and does …
National Commentary by Israel
During the GGE meeting of 11-15 April 2016, Israel presented its own domestic process for legal review of new weapons. Notwithstanding that Israel is not party to [AP I] and as such is not bound by Article 36 of that Protocol, Israel is of the …