Positions of States and Organisations

This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.

379 positions

2018 (continued)

  1. Statement by the Netherlands

    13 April 2018State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Article 36 of [API] contains the obligation to review whether the development or acquisition of new means and methods of warfare are permitted under international law. The Netherlands would like to underline that: (1) Efforts to ensure full and universal implementation of Article 36 procedures …

  2. Statement by the United Kingdom

    13 April 2018State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    2. … The UK’s clear position is that IHL and Article 36 Weapons Reviews are the applicable legal framework for the assessment and use of all weapons systems in armed conflict, including new and novel weapons technologies, in order to ensure their effects are thoroughly …

  3. Statement by the United States

    13 April 2018State or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Although we’ve heard the message from some States that weapons reviews are not sufficient, we think further consideration by this group of weapons reviews, without prejudice to other elements of the groups’ work, would be worthwhile. The United States remains interested in sharing practice on …

  4. Statement by the ICRC

    12 April 2018State or organisation: ICRCForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    The ICRC welcomes attention that this issue has brought to developing and improving legal review processes. The ICRC calls on all States to establish a weapon review mechanism or consider strengthening existing mechanisms to ensure that any new weapons that are developed and acquired can …

  5. Position Paper

    11 April 2018State or organisation: ChinaForum: GGE LAWS 2019

    4. In addition, national reviews on the research, development and use of new weapons have, to a certain extent, positive significance on preventing the misuse of relevant technologies and on reducing harm to civilians. However, as national policies and practices in this regard differ quite …

  6. Statement by Germany

    11 April 2018State or organisation: GermanyForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Only weapons that are operated in compliance with IHL are acceptable means of warfare. This might, as it is widely agreed on, only be assured as long as humans retain the sufficient control, at least over the critical functions of the weapons they operate, to …

  7. Statement by Poland

    11 April 2018State or organisation: PolandForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Having regard to the ethical dimension in the first place, we also recall that the principles of distinction, proportionality and precautions in attack are the fundamental rules and principles of international humanitarian law. They reflect efforts made by the international community to introduce effective legal …

  8. Statement by Switzerland

    11 April 2018State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Arguably, it might be possible in the future, to exert already a significant level of [human] control in the development and programming phase…Through legal reviews the capability to use a given system, in all or some circumstances, in compliance with international law can be verified.

  9. Statement by the Netherlands

    11 April 2018State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Given the fact that most [AWS] involve a high level of complexity, the Netherlands believes that the following elements are of importance: … The execution of legal weapon reviews that pay sufficient attention to the autonomy aspect of the [AWS]. If needed, boundaries could be …

  10. Statement by the United Kingdom

    11 April 2018State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Accountability measures are built in throughout the lifecycle of weapons systems — from concept, to initial development, through the assessment of legal use and acceptance into service, and ultimately the decision to deploy a system operationally. This is written into the technical standards governing their …

  11. Statement by the United Kingdom

    10 April 2018State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    3. … It [sic] not arbitrary, but it is a fact that no weapons system possessed by the UK is fully autonomous. Existing highly automated weapons meet the stringent standards of Article 36 legal weapons reviews. 6. … Focus on the level of human control …

  12. Statement by Australia

    9 April 2018State or organisation: AustraliaForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    We see the legal framework for reviewing new weapons, means and methods of warfare, under Article 36 of [API], as being of particular importance in ensuring this compliance. We should not overlook or under-value article 36 reviews. Australia would like to encourage in-depth discussion of …

  13. Statement by Belgium

    9 April 2018State or organisation: BelgiumForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    La Belgique considère qu’il est important de poursuivre les échanges sur la mise en œuvre de l’art.36 du 1er Protocole additionnel aux Conventions de Genève et l’obligation d’évaluer la licéité de toute nouvelle arme. Mon pays plaide pour l’universalisation de cet instrument et de la …

  14. Statement by Brazil

    9 April 2018State or organisation: BrazilForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Others appreciate the exchange and deepening of discussions on the challenges ahead, but do not readily accept that LAWS exist, or that entirely autonomous weapons systems will ever exit, because there will always be some degree of human oversight. They believe national assessments under Article …

  15. Statement by Bulgaria

    9 April 2018State or organisation: BulgariaForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Conducting legal weapon reviews under Article 36 of [AP I] plays a decisive role in guaranteeing that use and development of [LAWS] strictly comply with IHL norms. Information exchange on Article 36 mechanisms and procedures among State parties would be truly beneficial for improving the …

  16. Statement by Finland

    9 April 2018State or organisation: FinlandForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    When considering the human element in the use of lethal force, Finland believes that compliance with international humanitarian and human rights law is a key component. The notion that humans will now and in the future exert control over decisions of life and death needs …

  17. Statement by France (9 April 2018)

    9 April 2018State or organisation: FranceForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Au-delà de ces aspects fondamentaux, je souhaite rappeler les points essentiels pour ma délégation : … L’Article 36 du Protocole I additionnel aux Conventions de Genève, qui prévoit l’évaluation des nouveaux systèmes d’armes au regard du DIH, constitue un cadre de réflexion pertinent à cet …

  18. Statement by Greece

    9 April 2018State or organisation: GreeceForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    The legal framework necessary to ensure that any new weapons including LAWS, will be used in compliance with the provisions of International Law has already, been provided by Article 36 of [AP I] and, of course, by the Martens Clause.

  19. Statement by Italy

    9 April 2018State or organisation: ItalyForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    … international humanitarian law continues to apply fully to all weapons systems, including the potential development and use of LAWS. To this aim, conducting legal reviews of weapons, means and methods of warfare, in accordance with art. 36 of the Additional Protocol I to the …

  20. Statement by Pakistan

    9 April 2018State or organisation: PakistanForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    We are of the view that a Political Declaration or non-legally binding Code of Conduct comprising voluntary measures can only be an interim step towards a legally binding instrument. Similarly, the “weapon review” required under Article 36 of [AP I] is not sufficient to deal …

  21. Statement by Sri Lanka

    9 April 2018State or organisation: Sri LankaForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    While national legal reviews of new weapons may be a starting point, in the absence of a common definition on LAWS and global regulations, national reviews conducted based on inconsistent interpretations may not fully addressed the seriousness of the threats posed to humanity by LAWS.

  22. Statement by Sweden

    9 April 2018State or organisation: SwedenForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    … we would like to underline the importance of conducting legal reviews of new weapons, means and methods of warfare. We found the working papers on article 36 reviews, as well as on ensuring compliance with [IHL] presented to the meeting of the GGE very …

  23. Statement by Switzerland

    9 April 2018State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    Key elements of such a [political] declaration [by the CCW] could include: … In view of ensuring compliance, a reaffirmation of the obligation to review new weapons and to determine whether their employment would, in some or all circumstances, contravene existing international law; … Still …

  24. Statement by the European Union

    9 April 2018State or organisation: European UnionForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    … legal weapons reviews, as required by Article 36 of [AP I] are crucial. These require that States conduct legal reviews to establish, in each specific case, whether a weapon, means or method of warfare can be developed, acquired or used lawfully. Such reviews should …

  25. Statement by the ICRC

    9 April 2018State or organisation: ICRCForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    The ICRC welcomes efforts to improve implementation of IHL, including through enhancing mechanisms to review the legality of new weapons. Conducting legal reviews of weapon systems with autonomy in their critical functions can raise challenges, in particular regarding standards of predictability and reliability. The ICRC …

  26. Statement by the Netherlands

    9 April 2018State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    The unanimous conclusion by the High Contracting Parties that all weapon systems, including LAWS, and their deployment in armed conflict, must comply with the requirements set by international law, in particular [IHL]. In this light, we encourage all states to fulfil their obligations under article …

  27. Statement by the United Kingdom

    9 April 2018State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    5. Article 36 of [API] requires States to determine whether new weapons, means or methods of warfare may be employed lawfully under International Law. The United Kingdom takes this very seriously, and has published its weapons review procedures online in a document that sets out …

  28. Statement by the United States

    9 April 2018State or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    The United States places great importance on the weapon review process in the development and acquisition of new weapon systems. This is a critical measure in ensuring that weapon systems can dependably be used in a manner that is consistent with IHL

  29. Strengthening of the review mechanisms of a new weapon, means or methods of warfare

    4 April 2018State or organisation: ArgentinaForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    I. Introduction 1. International humanitarian law (IHL) aims at limiting the suffering engendered by war and mitigate its effects. To that end, IHL has become a complex set of norms comprised of six main treaties, additional treaties and a dense framework of customary norms that …

  30. Ethics and autonomous weapon systems: An ethical basis for human control?

    3 April 2018State or organisation: ICRCForum: GGE LAWS 2018

    From a legal perspective, when considering the obligation of States to review new weapons before their deployment and use under Article 36 of [AP I], it is difficult to see how a weapon system that autonomously changes its own functioning could ever be approved, since …