This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.
379 positions
2020 (continued)
National Commentary by Portugal
This Guiding Principle mimics much of the language used in Article 36 of Additional Protocol I (Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts). Moreover, Portugal notes that this Guiding Principle echoes …
National Commentary by Sweden
States have an obligation under international law (article 36 of AP I) to determine whether the employment of a new weapon would be prohibited under international law. In Sweden, this is carried out by the Delegation for International Humanitarian Law Monitoring of Arms Projects. All …
National Commentary by Japan
This principle is considered stipulating substantially the same provision as that of Article 36 of the Additional Protocol I of the Geneva Convention on August 12, 1949. Article 36 can be interpreted as obligating each High Contracting Party, in its research, development, acquisition or adoption …
National Commentary by Switzerland
Switzerland would like to recall the obligation of all States to “respect and ensure respect” for IHL (see common Article 1 to the Geneva Conventions) and the prohibition to use means and methods of warfare in contradiction to IHL. Therefore, an implementation of IHL in …
Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Switzerland
3.2 Procedure for assessing new weapons IHL legal framework Article 36 of Protocol I additional to the Geneva Conventions, which partly reflects customary international law,27 provides that in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, every state …
Operationalizing the Guiding Principles: A Roadmap for the GGE on LAWS
2. … Brazil would like to put forward four paths of action to build upon the guiding principles and fulfill the mandate of the GGE. The four paths, and its working methodology, are based on a “bottom-up” approach that benefits from domestic advancements in policies …
Parliamentary Commission Report
En France, le ministère des Armées a remis à plat les procédures internes relatives à l’examen de la licéité des armes ; une instruction a été communiquée en 2019 afin d’expliquer sa mise en application. Le champ d’application de l’article 36 du premier protocole additionnel …
National Commentary by Cuba
[22] It is an obligation of States to ensure that their weapons comply with the rules and principles of international law, including [IHL]. New technologies have to comply with international law as well. Article 36 of Protocol I Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 1977 …
National Commentary by Spain
To start with, States should assess, through legal reviews of new weapons and new methods of warfare, whether the level of human involvement in the new system would violate IHL. In case a legal review identifies a use that might be problematic, doctrine and training …
Commentary by the ICRC
States Parties to 1977 Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions have a legal obligation to conduct legal reviews of new weapons. In the ICRC’s view, the requirement to carry out legal reviews also flows from the obligation to ensure respect for IHL. Besides these …
National Commentary by Germany
Germany reaffirms that Guiding Principle (e) underlines the importance of human responsibility during the phases preceding the deployment of a weapon system. Particularly for highly complex systems with autonomous functions, the development phase is of crucial importance since the configurations determining the behavior of the …
National Commentary by France
In concrete terms, in order to ensure that IHL is fully applied to weapons systems based on emerging technologies in the area of LAWS – in compliance with guiding principle “a”5 and in line with their existing obligations – High Contracting Parties (HCPs) should, for …
National Commentary by Finland
A rigorous weapons review, in line with Article 36 of [AP I], is essential for determining the legality of any new means or method of warfare. In the area of emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence and machine autonomy, the review needs to be critical, …
Norway pledge on review of existing Norwegian Defence Sector implementation of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions article 36
A) Objectives of the pledge: Norway is a party to the Additional Protocol I of 1977 to the Geneva conventions of 1949 (AP I). The obligations under AP I article 36, is implemented within the Norwegian Defence Sector, by the “Norwegian Ministry of Defence, Directive …
Finland, CCW Annual Report
The Defense Command of Finland has issued a decree for the Finnish Defense Forces on the process of reviewing the legality of new weapons, means or methods of warfare in accordance with Article 36 of the 1977 Additional Protocol I to the 1949 Geneva Conventions.) …
National Commentary by Australia
Australia believes that an aspect of the current system of international law – embodied in Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949 contributes to the robust framework for regulating weapons systems, including those with autonomous functionality. Australia’s approach …
National Commentary by Italy
… in compliance with the guiding principle “e”4, the level of predictability and reliability of a weapon system must be assessed in the phases of testing, verification and certification, given that autonomous functions must be defined ex ante, starting from the stage of requirement, analysis …
Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Germany
b. Weapon Reviews Under the provisions of Art. 36 AP I, all contracting parties are obliged, when studying, developing, acquiring or adopting a new weapon, means or method of warfare, to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances of employment, be prohibited …
2019
ICRC IHL Challenges Report
E) Challenges Posed by Certain New Technologies of Warfare to Legal Reviews of New Weapons As noted above, the development and use of new technologies of warfare, such as autonomous weapon systems or military cyber capabilities, do not occur in a legal vacuum. As with …
United States, Military Manual (Land Warfare)
Ensuring the Legality of Weapons and Weapon Systems 2-200. Under longstanding DOD policies, there are requirements to review the legality of the acquisition or procurement of weapons. Although the United States is not a party to Additional Protocol I, many allies and potential multinational partners …
Questionnaire on the Legal Review Mechanisms of New Weapons, Means and Methods of Warfare
1. At the 2018 session of the CCW Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) on emerging technologies in the area of lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS), Argentina presented working paper CCW/GGE.1/2018/WP.2 on strengthening the legal weapons review mechanisms established in accordance with Article 36 of Additional …
Food for Thought Paper
6. In previous discussions, a number of States pointed to the importance of conducting legal reviews of new weapons, in accordance with international law and more particularly with article 36 of [API]. In our view, this remains a useful and important avenue to ensure that …
Implementing International Humanitarian Law in the Use of Autonomy in Weapon Systems
12. The legal review of weapons prior to their use enables the State developing or acquiring the weapons to consider relevant IHL issues, including precautions to reduce the risk of civilian casualties. The legal review of the weapon also affords an opportunity to ensure that …
Statement by Austria
We share the view expressed earlier that artificial intelligence and self-learning elements raise questions as to how frequently do an [AWS] would need to be reviewed. Weapons reviews are important measures to review the legality of new weapons. Weapon reviews are helpful to establish, whether …
Statement by New Zealand
As one of the few countries that undertakes Article 36 reviews for new weapons, munitions, methods and means of warfare, New Zealand encourages all States parties to [AP I] to fulfil their existing legal obligations for weapons reviews. New Zealand also supports any initiatives which …
Statement by New Zealand
Among the outcomes from this Group, New Zealand would like to see clear recognition of the importance of strengthening the operation of Art 36 reviews. We welcome the efforts being made by the ICRC to progress work on sharing best practice methods for conducting reviews …
Statement by the ICRC
The ICRC has welcomed the attention that this discussion has brought to improving and developing legal review processes. Effective legal reviews are critical to ensuring that a State’s armed forces comply with IHL in light of rapid technological developments. Greater transparency in how States interpret …
Statement by the Netherlands
The Netherlands believes that such a document [an interpretative guide or codes of conduct] should focus, amongst others, on meaningful human control in relation to the deployment of autonomous weapons, as well as on how to properly consider meaningful human control in the Article 36 …
Australia’s system of control and application for autonomous weapon systems
16. An important aspect of the review process is an Article 36 Review. In accordance with Australia’s obligation as a party to Protocol I Additional to the Geneva Convention, an Article 36 Review must be undertaken before a new weapon system can be introduced into …
Statement by Austria
… Lastly, we wish to address the issue of national weapon reviews, also referred to as Article 36 weapon reviews. The objective of these reviews is explicitly mentioned in our last years guiding principles. There seems to be convergence of views on the importance and …