Positions of States and Organisations

This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.

379 positions

2023 (continued)

  1. Statement by Australia (2nd intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: AustraliaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    So in answer to the question, “Can legal reviews by themselves ensure compliance with IHL?”, we don’t see it in of itself, sufficient to ensure compliance. We see legal reviews as an important check and balance within a broader system of control as reflective of …

  2. Statement by Austria

    9 March 2023State or organisation: AustriaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    As outlined by the address before in this discussion, the conduct of legal reviews is an existing obligation under Article 36 of [AP I], reaffirmed in our context for Guiding Principle (e). It is the task of our expert group to give additional guidance on …

  3. Statement by Bulgaria

    9 March 2023State or organisation: BulgariaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    … our delegation strongly supports the inclusion of the topic on the legal weapon reviews with regard to [AWS]. Being one of the key areas of convergence of growing convergence, a comprehensive and in-depth discussion on the subject matter is valuable and beneficial for the …

  4. Statement by China

    9 March 2023State or organisation: ChinaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Legal review is a provision in AP I of Geneva Conventions. All High Contracting Parties to the Geneva Conventions should strictly fulfil the obligations by carrying out legal reviews on AWS and other new weapons. Such reviews can help to prevent misuse of technology and …

  5. Statement by Denmark

    9 March 2023State or organisation: DenmarkForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    … Denmark considers weapons review as an essential tool in ensuring that all weapons systems are in compliance with IHL. As many have already mentioned, with Guiding Principle (e) this group has already highlighted the importance of weapons reviews. Like our Dutch colleague, we would …

  6. Statement by Ecuador

    9 March 2023State or organisation: EcuadorForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    … I would like to focus on the first part and the following three questions. The first question is key and the most important word there is the word insure. Because I don’t think that legal reviews by themselves cannot ensure compliance with IHL. It …

  7. Statement by France

    9 March 2023State or organisation: FranceForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    … we believe that states should commit themselves to adopt and implement national measures with a view of accompanying the development and employment of weapon systems that have autonomy, in order to guarantee full compliance with IHL. Such measures should cover the entire life-cycle of …

  8. Statement by Germany

    9 March 2023State or organisation: GermanyForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    The 2019 [GGE] adopted 11 guidelines reflect that “in accordance with states’ obligations under international law, in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or methods of warfare, determination must be made whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, …

  9. Statement by India

    9 March 2023State or organisation: IndiaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Our delegation would like to submit that India is not a party to [AP I]. There is no consonance between the list of countries who are party to [AP I] and the High Contracting Parties of the CCW. However, our delegation also submits that we …

  10. Statement by Israel

    9 March 2023State or organisation: IsraelForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    We wanted to join those calling for more discussions regarding national weapons reviews. Notwithstanding that Israel is not a party to [AP I], and as such is not bound by Article 36 of that Protocol, Israel is of the view that conducting legal reviews to …

  11. Statement by Japan

    9 March 2023State or organisation: JapanForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Legal reviews of weapons systems using emerging technologies in the area of LAWS, which are carried out with reregard to their research, development, acquisition, employment, as well as methods and means of warfare, is useful in determining whether they are prohibited by international law applicable …

  12. Statement by Mexico

    9 March 2023State or organisation: MexicoForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    We wish to begin by saying that we agree with you and with other delegations that have spoken here this morning. We believe that there is considerable convergence on this issue. It is true that current legal review obligations under IHL apply generally speaking to …

  13. Statement by Norway

    9 March 2023State or organisation: NorwayForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Norway too is a long-standing party to the Additional Protocol II [sic!] and Article 36 of course. Legal reviews are essential to ensuring compliance with international law as has been pointed out by so many and we very much support fleshing out what considerations the …

  14. Statement by Pakistan

    9 March 2023State or organisation: PakistanForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    We would also like to appreciate your deft handling of this body and your introduction under this topic, which we found very useful. Some very pertinent questions were raised by you. … [W]e can go with you, when you characterise our discussions under this topic, …

  15. Statement by Sweden (1st intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: SwedenForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    [A] s other delegations here today, Sweden like to underline the importance of conducting legal reviews of new weapons, means and methods of warfare. And we find working papers that engage with the obligation of Article 36 in relation to LAWS useful in the work …

  16. Statement by Sweden (2nd intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: SwedenForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    This is on the questions we had before lunch. We believe that legal reviews can assist in insurance compliance with IHL but it’s one of several tools in the tool-kit, including training and {operational} planning, etc. And it’s important that legal reviews are complete and …

  17. Statement by Switzerland

    9 March 2023State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    We are pleased to note that almost all proposals and working papers on the table stressed the importance of legal reviews of weapons. While not the sole solution for the challenges associated with increasing autonomy and weapon systems, legal reviews are a crucial instrument and …

  18. Statement by the ICRC

    9 March 2023State or organisation: ICRCForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    It’s been encouraging on this topic to see the attention given during discussions of [AWS] to the conduct of legal reviews. Effective legal reviews are a clear procedural obligation for states party to [AP I], and for all states are critical to ensuring that their …

  19. Statement by the Netherlands (1st intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    As we and many other states have mentioned, the ability to exercise human control and judgments during the development and use of [AWS] is key to ensure compliance with obligations under international law, in particular [IHL]. Conducting a legal review of [AWS] in line with …

  20. Statement by the Netherlands (2nd intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: NetherlandsForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    … to turn to your first questions, and these are, of course, kind of preliminary remarks, I would say that legal reviews by themselves are not the only tool to ensure compliance with IHL, and I agree with my colleague from Ecuador, who made the …

  21. Statement by the Philippines (1st intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: PhilippinesForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    There is much common ground among all delegations and in the respective proposals regarding the importance of weapons review at the national level. This, after all, is already an existing legal obligation. There is also growing recognition that exchange of information and good practices is …

  22. Statement by the Philippines (2nd intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: PhilippinesForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Well, my delegation would just like to express how encouraged we are with the tone of the discussions so far. And we take particular interest, and we’d like to echo some of the points that were raised by the distinguished delegation of Pakistan and Argentina, …

  23. Statement by the Russian Federation

    9 March 2023State or organisation: RussiaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Today we’re discussing a very important question in our view, a question that is related to questions of compliance with the provisions of IHL during the entire life-cycle of such weapon systems that we consider to be lethal autonomous weapons systems. We believe that at …

  24. Statement by the United Kingdom (1st intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    It is the United Kingdom’s strong belief that the requirement for an anticipatory ban or restrictions on [LAWS] is mitigated by the legal obligation on States to determine whether the employment of such a weapon system would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by …

  25. Statement by the United Kingdom (2nd intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Rather than trying to prevent you asked him some more challenging questions, actually I want to remind us of the homework you presented this week last night. And I want to perhaps now take the opportunity to answer or provide a UK response to one …

  26. Statement by the United States (1st intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    We appreciate the inclusion of legal reviews as a topic on your indicative timetable. The GGE’s mandate, of course, is to consider proposals and to elaborate by consensus possible measures. We believe that legal reviews are a particularly important measure in the context of [AWS] …

  27. Statement by the United States (2nd intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    This is, like our Swedish colleague, in response to your questions. Regarding the first question, my delegation agrees with what seems to be the consensus that legal reviews do not ensure compliance but are a very important measure. Regarding the second question, we do see …

  28. Proposal for an international legal instrument on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems

    8 March 2023State or organisation: PakistanForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    23. … National regulations and responses alone such as national weapons reviews are useful but not sufficient. The GGE is not the platform to confer legitimacy on national measures, which cannot be verified.

  29. Concept of activities of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation in the development and use of weapons systems

    7 March 2023State or organisation: RussiaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    3. … Adherence to the basic principles of IHL: distinction, proportionality, humanitarian considerations and military necessity should be mandatory, as well as legal review in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of new weapon types. …

  30. Draft articles on autonomous weapon systems

    6 March 2023State or organisation: AustraliaState or organisation: CanadaState or organisation: JapanState or organisation: Republic of KoreaState or organisation: United KingdomState or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Article 1: Preventing Autonomous Weapon Systems That, By Their Nature, Are Incapable of Use in Accordance With IHL IHL prohibits the use of an autonomous weapon system if it is of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering, if it is inherently indiscriminate, …