This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.
379 positions
2023 (continued)
Proposal for the normative and operational framework on autonomous weapons systems
If an AWS’ functioning is opaque, then humans responsible for the application of IHL rules — both persons entrusted with the legal review of an AWS and persons responsible for compliance with IHL during its use — could not reasonably determine its lawfulness under IHL …
Revised Working Paper
4. It is also a requirement throughout research, development, acquisition and use of [AWS] to constantly review and reassess any possible changes and modifications in the system’s functioning with regard to fulfilment of the conditions listed above. This should include technical aspects such as ‘machine …
Statement by the United Kingdom
We must also articulate the characteristics of these systems which may have positive or negative implications for compliance with IHL, and their impact upon activities throughout the life cycle of a weapon system, such as those elements that you mentioned in your introduction Mr Chair …
Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Italy
b. The procedure for evaluating new types of weapons According to art. 36 of the 1977 First Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions, States parties have an obligation to determine whether a new weapon under development, acquisition or adoption process could violate IHL59. This obligation …
2022
Application of international law to Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems
9. In line with Article 36 of [API], in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of LAWS, it should be determined whether their employment would, in some or all circumstances, fall under the prohibitions of international norms. Besides, it should be concluded whether they are …
Draft Protocol VI
Article 4: Review of Weapons Sec 1: Each High Contracting Party shall ensure that weapon systems under development or modification which changes the effects or use of existing weapon systems, including as a result of self-learning process, must be reviewed to ensure compliance with international …
Working Paper
B. In order to operationalize the two-tier approach, the HCP should: (b) Commit to only develop, produce, acquire, modify, deploy or use lethal weapons systems featuring autonomy when the following provisions are fulfilled: i. compliance with international law is ensured when studying, acquiring, adopting or …
Elements for a Legally Binding Instrument to Address the Challenges Posed by Autonomy in Weapon Systems
V. Legal Weapons Review 22. Legal weapons review must include an assessment that allows for the understanding of the attributes and effects in weapons with autonomous capabilities, as well as its conformity with international humanitarian law and international law, in particular: (a) Evaluate its technical …
Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) document on the application of International Humanitarian Law to Emerging Technologies in the Area of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS)
Annex A. Possible outline 1. The following is one possible outline for an IHL Manual as proposed by the UK, by way of illustration of the overall concept. It is based on eight headings, many of which reflect the concept, development and use cycle (‘lifecycle’ …
Principles and Good Practices on Emerging Technologies in the Area of LAWS
VIII. Good Practices Related to Human-Machine Interaction […] 26. At various stages of the life-cycle of a weapon, the following good practices related to human-machine interaction can strengthen compliance with international humanitarian law, strengthen accountability, and mitigate risks in the use of weapons systems based …
Roadmap Towards a New Protocol on Autonomous Weapons Systems
4. The current cycle of GGE shall aim to formally recognize the common elements that have arisen through constructive engagement among delegations throughout the CCW discussions on autonomous weapon systems (AWS), particularly in the last GGE cycle. These common elements include recognizing: … (h) the …
Working paper
1. This Working Paper sets out the following considerations and elements for the future work of the Group. The GGE should: … 13. Recall the obligation for States to conduct national weapon reviews, as codified in Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva …
Statement by Türkiye
Although Türkiye is not party to the Additional Protocol I to the [1949] Geneva Conventions (Additional Protocol I) relating to the protection of the victims in international armed conflicts, it fulfils its liabilities by investigating whether it is prohibited, according to the international law, as …
Canada, International Law Applicable in Cyberspace
50. States that are Parties to Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions are required to review new weapons, means or methods of warfare to ensure compliance with IHL.32 This obligation applies in the context of cyber capabilities and activities, although not all cyber capabilities …
Written Contributions on Possible Consensus Recommendations
Legal Framework & Norms … Legal reviews of new weapons means and methods of warfare are crucial to determining whether a system can be used in compliance with IHL — states must revise and develop methodologies and ensure rigorous reviews in step with the emergence …
France, Military Manual
5.6. The legal review of new weapons, means and methods of warfare Under Article 36 of AP I, in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, States parties are under an obligation to determine whether its employment …
2021
Building on Chile’s proposed four elements of further work
Weapons Reviews Relevant Guiding Principles: In accordance with States’ obligations under international law, in the study, development, acquisition, or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, determination must be made whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by …
Considerations for the report of the Group of Governmental Experts
15. The Russian Federation fully complies with its obligations under Article 36 of Additional Protocol I of 1977 (AP I) to the 1949 Geneva Conventions. Our country has a nationwide system which makes it possible, on the basis of the existing legal and regulatory framework, …
Joint Working Paper
9. … Our delegations are of the view that stronger focus should be given to the following principles, which should be the elements of a normative framework on LAWS: (j) … States should be transparent regarding all aspects of the development of their weapons systems, …
Outline for a normative and operational framework on emerging technologies in the area of LAWS
II. Operational Framework 3. To operationalize the principles enshrined in the normative framework, the High contracting Parties could agree on a compilation of measures and policies, to be implemented at national level: … (b) To operationalise the general provision 2c, an appropriate/sufficient scheme of human …
Possible consensus recommendations in relation to the clarification, consideration and development of aspects on the normative and operational framework on emerging technologies in the area of LAWS
9. … within the future normative and operational framework, High Contracting Parties should: … ii. Undertake and implement national policies and measures in order to regulate the development and use of partially autonomous lethal weapons systems, guided by the following principles: (i) ensure full compliance …
U.S. Proposals on Aspects of the Normative and Operational Framework
D. U.S. Proposals on Weapons Reviews Guidelines and good practices for militaries to consider using in conducting legal reviews of weapons systems based on emerging technologies in the area of LAWS 11. Legal advisers should be consulted regularly in the development or acquisition process as …
Written contribution of France on possible consensus recommendations
This paper is submitted under the responsibility of the Chair. The following are elements for discussion for possible inclusion in the report of the GGE, which will be prepared at a later stage. This paper does not prejudge the outcome of the 2021 GGE session, …
Written contribution of Estonia on possible consensus recommendations
5. … Estonia welcomes the addition of a section dedicated to weapons reviews in the draft elements of possible consensus recommendations. We agree, inter alia, that weapons reviews should be conducted when a weapon is modified or used differently from its original intended use. Estonia …
Answers by Spain to the Guiding Questions
Which decisions, activities, and processes across the life-cycle of a weapons system would collectivelycontribute towards and enable appropriate human-machine interaction/human control/human judgment?What would be the interaction between these various decisions, activities, and processes and how would theyvary based on the operational context and the characteristics …
Answers by the Netherlands to the Guiding Questions
Where and how to draw the line to determine what [AWS] would be lawful or not? … the article 36 review process is critical in this process of determining whether a weapon system is capable of being used in compliance with IHL. As the Netherlands …
Statement by Poland
Section 5 — Weapon reviews 1. In para 1 we see the need to invoke article 36 of [API]. The new para would read as follows: “In accordance with the obligations of States under international law, in relation to Art. 36 of [API], in the …
Statement by Israel
In an effort to contribute to the [Article 5] discussions, Israel has actively participated in the meetings, contributed with participation of relevant experts and also took the opportunity to elaborate on its weapons review procedure… Lastly, another issue that seems to necessitate further discussions is …
Statement by Japan
In order to ensure that the military use of emerging technologies in the area of LAWS is in compliance with international legal obligations, particularly [IHL], we must carefully study the use in the entire life cycle of weapons systems. In particular, the hardware and software …
Statement by Malta
My delegation believes that conducting reviews as specified in article 36 of [AP I] provides an important role in weapons development and likewise that through such reviews, it is more likely to establish whether new technologies in the area of LAWS should be prohibited or …