This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.
379 positions
2026 (continued)
Statement by Ukraine
As for paragraph 39, We recognize that this paragraph largely reflects the duty found in Article 36 of Additional Protocol I. Some States, acting in their sovereign right, chose not to join the Protocol. However, we also know that some States not parties to the …
Statement by Czechia
We also welcome the clarification that human beings may exercise such control directly or indirectly. We understand this wording as recognizing that relevant human judgment may be exercised at different stages of a system's lifecycle, including during legal review, testing and evaluation, and in preparation …
Statement by Egypt
… On a positive note, we welcome the restoration of article 36 consistent trigger language at paragraph 38 ….
Statement by Ukraine
Human rights law is a frequently cited example of other law that applies in armed conflict, but we must also be mindful of international maritime law, international air and space law, the law of state responsibility, and other areas of law. To support the mention …
Statement by Nigeria
… The provision concerning responsible chains of human command and control, limitations on targets and operational parameters, timely deactivation or neutralization, legal reviews, testing and evaluation, predictability, reliability, traceability, explainability, and the mitigation of unintended and automation bias are essential. …
Statement by Türkiye
… paragraph 39 now incorporates language directly drawn from Article 36 of Additional Protocol I. As my delegation is not party to that instrument, we cannot accept language that imports treaty-specific obligations into a document intended to reflect common understanding among all states, including non-parties. …
Statement by APILS and Utrecht University
Our most fundamental concern with this box, also shared by others who have intervened today, is that it does not sufficiently distinguish between legal obligations and other measures. This blurring occurs as a result of the conduct of legal reviews being placed under a chapeau …
REAIM Pathways to Action
… 7. Building on the Call to Action advanced at the REAIM Summit 2023 in The Hague and the Blueprint for Action advanced at the REAIM Summit 2024 in Seoul, convinced that the time has come to take steps towards operationalization of the principles reflected …
2025
Statement by Israel
There is a reason why definitions of weapons are based on design in particular since they delineate more clearly the types of weapons under consideration and since they better reflect the element of intended circumstances of use which is a crucial element in defining and …
Statement by APILS
The chapeau of this box concludes with the word “should”, indicating that the paragraphs that follow reflect desirable measures or good practices. But this creates some issues in relation to paragraphs 1 and 9. As several delegations have underlined, the obligation to undertake legal reviews …
Canada, Military Manual
Section 2. CAF-Issued Weapons and Ammunition 4. Canada is obligated to review new weapons, means and methods of warfare for compliance with LOAC before they are authorized for CAF use. CAF commanders and members can have confidence that CAF-issued weapons and ammunition are lawful for …
Statement by Australia
Australia supports the inclusion of Paragraphs 1 to 4 in this box which addresses the legal review of LAWS to ensure compliance with international humanitarian law. We believe strengthening compliance with existing IHL including through Article 36 legal reviews is the most effective way to …
Statement by Israel
Article 36 itself states that, in the development of a new weapon, a High Contracting Party is under the obligation to determine whether its employment will be prohibited by [Additional] Protocol [I] or by any other applicable rule of international law, meaning the Article does …
Statement by Pakistan
…ensuring IHL compliance must begin at the development stage. And right now many Delegations have pointed out—delegation of Italy also has pointed out—that Article 36 of the Additional Protocol I of the Geneva Conventions do affirm the necessity of ensuring compliance with IHL from the …
Statement by the United States
I would draw your attention to our proposals in the 24th Draft Article, proposal joined by a number of other Delegations, where we have expressed the idea that autonomous weapons systems may only to be developed such that their effects and attacks are capable of …
Statement by Austria
[W]e also support to switch out "employment" to "development and use". The whole life-cycle issue has been discussed also since a long time and this is something we definitely support. It is important as what we are doing here is upholding IHL, and IHL does …
Statement by Sierra Leone
As a cosponsor of Draft Protocol VI, Sierra Leone notes the significant convergence between that protocol and the rolling text, particularly regarding the application of international humanitarian law, the need for human control, prohibitions on certain systems, weapons reviews, human responsibility and risk mitigation.
2024
Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Australia
Does the government conduct legal reviews under Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to determine whether new weapons, means or methods of warfare may be employed in accordance with Australia’s international legal obligations? Article 36 of Additional Protocol I requires that: In the study, development, …
Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in the United Kingdom
3. What is the United Kingdom’s approach to reviewing weapons? a) Does the Government conduct a legal review to determine whether new weapons and means or methods of warfare may be employed lawfully? Article 36 of AP I requires States to determine whether new weapons, …
REAIM Blueprint for Action
… Building on the Call to Action laid out at the REAIM Summit 2023, we invite all stakeholders including states, industry, academia, civil society, regional and international organizations to: … Implementing AI in the military domain … 11. Encourage the development of effective legal review …
ICRC IHL Challenges Report
States use various domestic processes to implement their IHL obligations. Legal review of new weapons, means and methods of warfare is one such process mandated by IHL. Carrying out a legal review of any new weapon, means or method of warfare they develop or acquire …
Singapore Statement for Expert Meeting on Legal Review of AWS
While Singapore is not a party to AP I, reviews of weapon systems are conducted as part of a rigorous defence procurement process. These reviews are conducted at each stage of capability development, planning, delivery and sustainment in a systematic and coordinated manner involving relevant …
Statement by Argentina
We suggest that there is a need to strengthen the issue of responsibility in the creation and production of autonomous systems, making them auditable and limiting to the black box. In 2018 and 2019, we presented two documents emphasizing the existing obligations to carry out …
Statement by the Russian Federation
As we said before, obligations under Article 36 of Additional Protocol I do not provide for an automatic prohibition of one or other kind of weapons as not in line with the requirements of IHL because of the objective impossibility of providing for and taking …
Draft articles on autonomous weapon systems
Article 1. Preventing Autonomous Weapon Systems That, By Their Nature, Are Incapable of Use in Accordance With IHL IHL prohibits the use of an autonomous weapon system if it is of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering, if it is inherently indiscriminate, …
Statement by Argentina
Argentina stresses the validity of the obligation to carry out weapons reviews within the framework of Article 36 of the AP1 to Geneva Conventions of 1949.
Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in New Zealand
Procedures For Assessing New Weapons 91. New Zealand is required to assess the legality of new weapons or means or methods of warfare.83 As part of the assessment, New Zealand must determine whether employment would, in some or all circumstances, violate the rules of Additional …
Submission by Brazil to the Secretary-General
Therefore, it should be in the interest of States and private companies to draw clear standards, in order to avoid exposure to legal risk as a consequence of violations of IHL committed with the use of AWS that they have developed, produced, acquired or deployed.
Submission by the Republic of Moldova to the Secretary-General
[…] existing international humanitarian law (Article 36 "New Weapons" of the First Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions, signed on 12 August 1949) provides that "in the research, development, acquisition or adoption of new means or methods of warfare, a High Contracting Party shall be …
Submission by Argentina to the Secretary-General
In 2018 and 2019, Argentina presented documents CCW/GGE.1/2018/WP.2 and CCW/GGE.1/2019/WP.6, highlighting the existing obligations to conduct weapons assessments under Article 36 of the 1977 Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions of 1949[.]