Positions of States and Organisations

This database currently contains 379 positions and is continuously updated. Any corrections, or suggestions to add material, are welcome.

379 positions

2024 (continued)

  1. Submission by Japan to the Secretary-General

    24 May 2024State or organisation: JapanForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    6. Legal review (a) In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, it must, in accordance with the obligations of states under international law, be determined whether their use/employment is prohibited by international law in some or …

  2. Submission by Sweden to the Secretary-General

    15 May 2024State or organisation: SwedenForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    Review process States are obligated to determine whether the employment of a new weapon would be prohibited under international law. In Sweden, this is carried out by the Delegation for International Humanitarian Law Monitoring of Arms Projects. All defence-related authorities must, without delay, report to …

  3. Submission by Australia to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: AustraliaForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    Legal review of LAWS 22. Legal reviews are a critical safeguard for ensuring all weapons systems are capable of being used in compliance with IHL. A legal review (often referred to as a ‘weapons review’) is the process by which States determine the lawfulness of …

  4. Submission by Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Guatemala, Kazakhstan, Nigeria, Panama, Peru, the Philippines, Sierra Leone and State of Palestine to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: ChileState or organisation: ColombiaState or organisation: Costa RicaState or organisation: Dominican RepublicState or organisation: EcuadorState or organisation: El SalvadorState or organisation: GuatemalaState or organisation: KazakhstanState or organisation: NigeriaState or organisation: PanamaState or organisation: PeruState or organisation: PhilippinesState or organisation: Sierra LeoneState or organisation: State of PalestineForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    The draft Protocol includes a preamble and eight (8) articles: (1) General Provisions, (2) Characterization, (3) Prohibitions, (4) Regulations, (5) Review of Weapons, (6) Risk Mitigation, (7) Compliance, and (8) Consultations of High Contracting Parties …. [Annex: CCW/GGE.1/2023/WP.6]

  5. Submission by India to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: IndiaForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    Particular importance is attached to the conclusions contained in the Report of the 2023 session of the Group of Governmental Experts on Emerging Technologies in the Area of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems which state inter alia that:- … “In accordance with States’ obligations under international …

  6. Submission by Italy to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: ItalyForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    In addition to these principles, Art. 35 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions reaffirms that methods and means or warfare are not unlimited, a concept that is operationalised by art. 36, which imposes an obligation on States parties to ensure unlawful weapons are …

  7. Submission by New Zealand to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: New ZealandForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    17. Weapons reviews4 are an important part of national obligations to respect and ensure respect for IHL, and New Zealand supports their strengthening. While weapons reviews are necessary for AWS, New Zealand sees these as insufficient on their own to address concerns about AWS and …

  8. Submission by Sri Lanka to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: Sri LankaForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    14. Sri Lanka welcomes adoption of non-binding voluntary measures such as Codes of Conduct and political declarations on the use of AWS as progressive developments. However, such measures would only be of complementary value strengthening the normative framework on the issue given their insufficiency to …

  9. Submission by the Philippines to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: PhilippinesForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    7. Weapons review. A crucial implication of the applicability of international law is that states have an obligation to undertake national weapons review. In the study, development, acquisition, or adoption of any new weapon, means or method of warfare, determination must be made whether its …

  10. Submission by the Russian Federation to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: RussiaForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    The 1977 Additional Protocol I (AP I) to the Geneva Conventions of 1949 also contains an important obligation regarding conduction of legal reviews during the study, development, acquisition or adoption of new weapons. Meanwhile, the article 36 does not contain any provisions on how exactly …

  11. Submission by the United Kingdom to the Secretary-General

    May 2024State or organisation: United KingdomForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    [U]nder IHL the right of the Parties to a conflict to choose methods or means of warfare is not unlimited. This is emphasised by the obligation on States, under Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, to determine whether the employment of …

  12. Statement by Belgium

    7 March 2024State or organisation: BelgiumForum: GGE LAWS 2024

    … although for Belgium the adoption of an international legally binding instrument looking to prohibit and regulate autonomous weapon systems is necessary, my delegation nevertheless thinks that national legal reviews are the best way to fully implement the obligations contained in an international instrument, whether …

  13. Statement by Switzerland

    7 March 2024State or organisation: SwitzerlandForum: GGE LAWS 2024

    While not the sole solution for the challenges associated with increasing autonomy in weapons systems, legal reviews are a crucial instrument and thus can be part of the solution. A well-designed weapons review mechanism has not only the potential to determine whether or not an …

  14. Statement by China

    6 March 2024State or organisation: ChinaForum: GGE LAWS 2024

    … legal review is stipulated in Protocol I of the Geneva Conventions. All states parties should strictly implement their obligations. Most states parties, including China, have relevant review and evaluation mechanisms as a CBM. Countries are encouraged to formulate corresponding legal review mechanism in light …

  15. Statement by the ICRC

    6 March 2024State or organisation: ICRCForum: GGE LAWS 2024

    Effective legal reviews are a clear obligation for states that are party to Additional Protocol I and, for all states, they’re critical to ensuring that their armed forces comply with IHL rules in the use of any weapon systems. And the ICRC endorses the view, …

  16. Reply by Estonia to the Chair’s Guiding Questions

    1 March 2024State or organisation: EstoniaForum: GGE LAWS 2024

    Weapons reviews are a valuable tool to ensure the compliance of a specific LAWS with international law. We find that in addition to conducting a weapons review when a new weapons system is taken into use, a weapons review should also be conducted when a …

  17. Czech Republic, Position Paper on the Application of International Law in Cyberspace

    27 February 2024State or organisation: CzechiaForum: Domestic

    38. Principles and rules of IHL applicable in armed conflict govern all forms of warfare and all means or methods of warfare, including those of the future.28 This is confirmed also by Article 36 of Additional Protocol I requiring States to review the lawfulness of …

  18. Submission by Canada to the Secretary-General

    2024State or organisation: CanadaForum: UNGA Res 78/241

    In accordance with Article 36 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, Canada conducts national legal reviews of new weapons, means or methods of warfare, to ensure IHL compliance. Canada ensures this necessary element first through its national legal reviews of all new weapons, …

  19. Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Argentina

    2024State or organisation: ArgentinaForum: IC RCRC

    8. Nuevas armas En relación con los procedimientos formales para el examen de la legalidad de nuevas armas, de acuerdo con la normativa que regula las distintas actividades que desempeñan las Fuerzas Armadas, los nuevos desarrollos deben ser sometidos al análisis de legalidad dentro de …

  20. Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Canada

    2024State or organisation: CanadaForum: IC RCRC

    Determination of whether new weapons and means or methods of warfare may be employed lawfully Canada conducts weapons reviews in accordance with Article 36 of AP I. In the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, Canada has …

  21. Voluntary Report on the Implementation of IHL in Ukraine

    2024State or organisation: UkraineForum: IC RCRC

    3. Legal review of weapons under Article 36 of Additional Protocol I. What is done? The obligation to conduct a legal review of weapons is established by Article 36 of Additional Protocol I, that defines an obligation of the State during the study, development, acquisition …

2023

  1. Letter (No 1) from the Minister of State for Defence Procurement

    13 November 2023State or organisation: United KingdomForum: Domestic

    ‘Article 36’ weapons reviews The United Kingdom is legally obliged to ensure that all weapons and associated equipment that it obtains, plans to acquire, or develops comply with the UK's treaty and other obligations under International Humanitarian Law (specifically Article 36 of The First Protocol …

  2. Letter (No 2) from the Minister of State for Defence Procurement

    13 November 2023State or organisation: United KingdomForum: Domestic

    2.3 ‘Black Box’ AI and Article 36 Reviews As noted in my previous letter, Article 36 Reviews are conducted to ensure that a weapon is capable of being used lawfully, having regard to all of the principles of IHL, in the context of its use …

  3. Costa Rica’s Position on the Application of International Law in Cyberspace

    21 July 2023State or organisation: Costa RicaForum: OEWG Cyber 2021–2025

    56. The legality of all new weapons, means and methods of warfare, including cyber capabilities, must be systematically assessed by all States. IHL requires that in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of any new weapon, means or method of warfare, States must determine whether …

  4. Draft articles on autonomous weapon systems

    15 May 2023State or organisation: AustraliaState or organisation: CanadaState or organisation: JapanState or organisation: PolandState or organisation: Republic of KoreaState or organisation: United KingdomState or organisation: United StatesForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Article 1. Preventing Autonomous Weapon Systems That, By Their Nature, Are Incapable of Use in Accordance With IHL IHL prohibits the use of an autonomous weapon system if it is of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering, if it is inherently indiscriminate, …

  5. Draft Protocol on Autonomous Weapon Systems (Protocol VI)

    11 May 2023State or organisation: ArgentinaState or organisation: ColombiaState or organisation: Costa RicaState or organisation: EcuadorState or organisation: El SalvadorState or organisation: GuatemalaState or organisation: KazakhstanState or organisation: NigeriaState or organisation: PanamaState or organisation: PeruState or organisation: PhilippinesState or organisation: Sierra LeoneState or organisation: State of PalestineState or organisation: UruguayForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Article 5: Review of Weapons Sec. 1: Each High Contracting Party shall ensure that weapon systems under development or modification which changes the effects or use of existing weapon systems, including as a result of self-learning processes, must be reviewed to ensure compliance with international …

  6. Statement by the United Kingdom under agenda item 5, topic 6

    10 March 2023State or organisation: United KingdomForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    The UK would strongly support further work in the GGE that focussed on sharing and collating good practice relating to the various activities throughout the life cycle of a weapon system which would impact upon compliance with IHL. This includes but is not limited to …

  7. Statement by Algeria

    9 March 2023State or organisation: AlgeriaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    … At the outset, I’d like to say that answers to some of the questions have already been included in, or covered by, the statement made by the delegation of Algeria earlier this morning. But as part of our interactive debate, I would like to …

  8. Statement by Argentina

    9 March 2023State or organisation: ArgentinaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    Reviews of new weapons systems in the context of rapid pace of technological advancement requires scientific and technical capacities that in connection with [AWS] will clearly show the gap in the positions of states when they analyse new technologies and their compliance with international law. …

  9. Statement by Australia (1st intervention)

    9 March 2023State or organisation: AustraliaForum: GGE LAWS 2023

    My delegation welcomes a discussion on legal reviews of autonomous weapons systems. We see this topic as particularly ripe for further elaboration in the GGE, as – to our mind – effective practices in relation to weapons reviews have the potential to address many of …